Stick it in His Gut

Kaspar would like nothing more than to scream out for his fallen comrade, but he knows better. Better to kill the beast once and for all then to draw it's attention back and die alongside Castille.

Not even a whisper leaves his lips as Kaspar maneuvers himself next to the gator and thrust his blade as hard he can at its soft belly.

Here we go again. Two-handed flanking attack allows the sneak bonus. Rolled a ... 18! (Tim dances) That's a possible crit with the rapier. Just for good measure, the total is 18+3+2(flanking bonus)=23. Rolling again ... 7+3+2=12. If I can spend an action die on the second roll I will, giving me an extra ... 1. Damn.

Damage for the first attack, assuming no crit, comes out at 5+4+2=11.